Adapting Pedagogy to Learners' Needs
It is essential to begin this article by acknowledging that every learner is unique and may face varying challenges and accommodations that must be considered. Please note that this article does not aim to provide a comprehensive overview of every aspect of teaching. Rather, it serves as a resource to promote awareness and offer insights into the topic and is grounded in both empirical research and anecdotal evidence.
First published online August 24, 2024
Kelsey Tilley
Keywords: Pedagogy; home education; autism; adhd; dyslexia; inclusive education; student-centered; Waldorf education
In this article, we explore adaptive pedagogy and its effectiveness in home education, particularly for neurodivergent learners such as those with Autism, ADHD, and dyslexia. By breaking down approaches like differentiated instruction, Universal Design for Learning, and the social model of disability, we emphasize the importance of tailoring educational methods to individual needs. We demonstrate how adaptive pedagogy creates an inclusive learning environment that respects and supports diverse learning styles, ultimately enabling all students to thrive. Readers will gain insights into how these strategies can create a more personalized and equitable educational experience for every learner.
Are standard teaching methods fully addressing the diverse needs of your learners? Discover how adaptive strategies can elevate engagement and amplify each student's potential.
What is Adaptive Pedagogy?
Adaptive pedagogy is an educational approach that tailors teaching methods, materials, and strategies to meet the unique and evolving learning needs of a student. It differs from the conventional pedagogic model that is a fixed teaching model for all learners regardless of the special needs that learners may have. This approach recognizes and takes in consideration the different learning styles, strengths, and challenges of each individual learner. It involves regularly assessing and monitoring a learner’s progress, needs and adjusting accordingly. This often involves offering additional support, adapting the teaching style to the learning style of the learner, or offering alternative ways for the student to demonstrate their understanding of the curriculum. The aim of adaptive pedagogy is to provide the needed support, tools and inclusive environment for the student to flourish and meet their potential for success.
The Importance of Adaptive Pedagogy
An adaptive pedagogical approach can play a key role in facilitating effective learning. By carefully observing and responding to a learner’s unique educational needs, an educator can make real-time adjustments, providing individualized support and a tailored curriculum that creates an inclusive and collaborative environment. This approach ensures that every learner feels valued and capable, laying the groundwork for meaningful engagement with the curriculum.
One of the main benefits of adaptive pedagogy is that it directly addresses the barriers that prevent a learner from reaching their educational potential. These barriers could include language and communication differences, varying cognitive abilities, socio-emotional challenges, and diverse learning styles. When teaching methods do not align with an individual learner’s needs, it can lead to frustration and hinder their ability to engage with the curriculum and retain information effectively.
Assessing Learner’s Needs: TOI Method & VARK Model
In a home education environment, understanding the needs of the learner is the foundation to being able to accommodate and adapt the curriculum. There are many methods of doing this including using Howard Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences and the VARK model.
Theory of Multiple Intelligences
With Howard Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences method it can be identified whether the learner excels in linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, musical, interpersonal, intrapersonal, or naturalistic intelligences. These assessments can be found free of charge online.
Linguistic Intelligence - The ability to effectively use language, whether spoken or written, to express thoughts, convey ideas, and understand others. Learners with this intelligence prefer reading, writing, storytelling, or engaging in discussions.
Logical-Mathematical Intelligence - The capacity to reason, think critically, and solve problems through logical patterns and mathematical reasoning. These learners excel in problem-solving activities, logical puzzles, and analytical tasks.
Spatial Intelligence - The skill to visualize and manipulate objects and concepts in a three-dimensional space. Learners with spatial intelligence prefer working with maps, charts, diagrams, and visual arts, often understanding concepts better through imagery.
Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence - The ability to use one's physical body skillfully to solve problems, create products, or express ideas. These learners benefit from hands-on activities, physical movement, and learning through doing.
Musical Intelligence - The talent for understanding, creating, and interpreting musical patterns. Learners with this intelligence prefer rhythm, melodies, and musical activities, often using music as a tool for memorization or emotional expression.
Interpersonal Intelligence - The capacity to understand others and work effectively with them. Learners strong in this intelligence thrive in group activities, discussions, and collaborative learning environments where they can interact with peers.
Intrapersonal Intelligence - The ability to understand oneself, including one's emotions, motivations, and goals. These learners prefer self-reflection, journaling, and activities that allow them to set personal goals and work independently.
Naturalistic Intelligence - The skill to observe, recognize, and categorize natural objects such as plants and animals. Learners with this intelligence are drawn to outdoor activities, environmental topics, and learning experiences that involve nature.
VARK Model
In addition, the VARK model developed by Neil Fleming in the late 1980s will provide invaluable information whether the learner is a visual, auditory, reading/writing, or kinesthetic learner.
Visual Learners:
Prefer to learn through seeing.
Benefit from diagrams, charts, graphs, and visual representations.
Remember information better when it is presented visually.
Auditory Learners:
Prefer to learn through listening.
Benefit from lectures, discussions, and audio recordings.
Retain information better when they hear it.
Reading/Writing Learners:
Prefer to learn through reading and writing.
Benefit from text-based resources, such as books, articles, and notes.
Learn best by reading and taking notes.
Kinesthetic Learners:
Prefer to learn through hands-on experiences and movement.
Benefit from practical activities, experiments, and real-world examples.
Learn best when they can touch, manipulate, or experience what they are learning.
Assessing a learner's needs is a continuous process that requires monitoring and adaptation. As the learner progresses, regular check-ins through quizzes, discussions, and observational feedback enable the educator to refine their teaching strategies to better suit the learner’s evolving needs. This may even mean changing teaching methods from assignment to assignment. It is also important to note that it may be beneficial to synthesize learning styles to expose learners to a broader set of techniques, potentially improving how they retain information.
Differentiated Instruction
Differentiated instruction is based on the belief that students learn in different ways and at different paces, and that teaching should be flexible enough to adapt to these variations. It is built on several core elements: content, process, and product.
Differentiating content means offering learners different ways to access the material being taught. This might involve offering a variety of resources, such as books, videos, or hands-on materials, to cater to the learner’s preferred learning style.
Differentiating the process involves varying the activities and strategies used to help the learner engage with the curriculum. For example, one learner might benefit from working independently, while another might need more collaborative activities or direct instruction.
Differentiating the product means allowing the learner to demonstrate their understanding in different ways, such as through a written report, a presentation, or a creative project.
Differentiated instruction allows the learner to progress through the curriculum at a faster pace when they quickly grasp concepts or slow down to receive more support, practice, and the necessary time to learn without frustration or exhaustion. This requires ongoing assessment and observation to identify when adjustments to the curriculum are necessary to maintain optimal learning conditions.
Universal Design for Learning
Universal Design for Learning is a transformative approach that provides flexible learning pathways, catering to the diverse needs of all students. This approach focuses on three core principles: engagement (why), representation (what), and action and expression (how), ensuring that every learner has an opportunity to succeed.
What makes this method particularly effective is its proactive approach to curriculum design, which emphasizes providing multiple means of engagement and tapping into learners' interests and motivations. By allowing students to express their understanding in various ways such as through art, presentations, or hands-on projects—UDL enables them to demonstrate their learning in the manner that best suits their strengths, fostering a more inclusive and personalized learning experience.
"Pedagogy must evolve to meet the learner where they are, turning obstacles into stepping stones on their path to understanding."
Waldorf Methodology
Waldorf methodology supports adapting pedagogy to the individual needs of each learner, emphasizing the holistic development of the child across intellectual, emotional, and physical growth. The foundation of this approach is the understanding that every child possesses unique potential, and the curriculum is designed to be flexible, meeting students where they are in terms of age, abilities, and personal needs. For special needs children, this ideology is reflected in a focus on nurturing the whole child including the body, mind, and spirit through a balanced, artistic curriculum that incorporates individualized approaches, consistent rhythms, and inclusive environments. This ensures that all learners, regardless of their learning style, engage with the curriculum in a way that supports their strengths and respects their developmental pace.
Student Centered Learning
Student-centered learning is an educational approach that shifts the focus of instruction from the teacher to the student. Rather than being passive recipients of information, learners are encouraged to take an active role in their own learning process, thereby encouraging a deeper investment, understanding and retention of knowledge. It places the attention on each learner's specific needs, interests, and abilities, making the student an integral part of their learning process in their education, which leads to a stronger connection and comprehension of the curriculum.
The benefits of student-centered learning are manifold, extending far beyond academic achievement and making use of skillsets that extend into real-world settings. One of the most significant advantages is the development of critical thinking and problem-solving skills. In a student-centered approach, students are often tasked with exploring complex issues, and coming up with innovative solutions to real-world problems. By giving students a voice in their learning process, educators can help them develop a sense of ownership and responsibility for their education, leading to a more engaged learning experience.
In a student-centered environment, a teacher might recognize that a traditional assignment, such as writing a report on the biomes of the Earth, could be particularly challenging for a student with communication challenges. Understanding the student's interests and strengths, the educator decides to adapt the assignment to better engage the learner by asking them to write a letter to their favorite game character. In this letter, the student is tasked with explaining how the character's next game should be set in specific biomes and detailing why these environments would be appropriate for the game. This change aligns with the student's passion for gaming and special interest as an autistic learner and thus makes the task more relatable and enjoyable. As a result, what started as a frustrating assignment turned into an engaging project, leading the student to produce a three-page report filled with creativity and detailed explanations. This example highlights how student-centered learning can transform educational experiences by adapting to individual needs and leveraging personal interests to foster success.
Neurodivergence and Education
Autism
When adapting a curriculum for autistic learners, it's important to understand that each learner has a unique way of processing information and interacting with the world. Autism is a complex and diverse condition, and there are many nuances that contribute to how each learner experiences it. Some autistic learners may process information visually, benefiting from visual aids, charts, and diagrams, while others may be more hands-on, learning best through tactile experiences and practical activities. Some students might have heightened sensory sensitivities, requiring a quieter or less stimulating environment to focus, whereas others may need frequent movement breaks or fidget tools to accommodate their need to stim. In addition, some autistic learners might flourish with structured routines and clear, consistent instructions, while others may require more flexibility and time to transition between activities. Communication styles can also vary; some students might communicate better through written text or alternative communication devices, while others might need additional time to process verbal instructions.
Given the complexities of autism, it's important to recognize that not every aspect of it can be covered in this brief overview. Understanding the specific needs of each autistic learner requires careful observation and a willingness to try different approaches to see what works best. By tailoring educational approaches to fit these individual needs, educators can create a more inclusive environment where every student has the opportunity to thrive. This isn't just about making learning more accessible; it's about recognizing and valuing the diverse ways in which autistic students learn.
Consider a student named Andy, who is autistic and has a special interest in trains. In a traditional classroom setting, a history lesson on transportation might cover various modes of travel over the centuries. However, by adapting the curriculum to Andy’s special interests, the educator could design the lesson to focus specifically on the evolution of train systems. The teacher could include activities such as creating a timeline of key train developments, researching the impact of trains on various societies, or even organizing a field trip to photograph trains. This personalized approach not only captures Andy’s attention but also encourages active participation and a more in-depth understanding of the historical content, ultimately leading to more effective learning outcomes.
ADHD
Adapting the curriculum for learners with ADHD necessitates a thoughtful approach that takes into account the diverse ways they process information and engage with their environment. ADHD manifests differently in each student, making it important to tailor educational methods to fit individual needs. Some things that should be taken into consideration could be:
Movement Integration: Incorporate physical activities into lessons, such as interactive experiments or role-playing, to help students with ADHD stay engaged.
Task Management: Break down assignments into smaller, manageable steps, and offer flexibility in the order of completion to reduce overwhelm and enhance focus.
Sensory Needs: Provide different learning environments, such as quiet spaces for concentration or areas with background noise, depending on what helps the student focus better.
Choice and Autonomy: Allow students to make choices about their learning activities, which can increase motivation and investment in the material.
These strategies highlight just a few of the many ways ADHD can influence learning. It’s important to remember that each learner’s experience with ADHD is unique, and finding the right approach often involves observation and experimentation. By personalizing educational approaches, educators can create a learning environment that supports academic success and builds a learner’s confidence.
For instance, imagine a student named Sam who has ADHD and a passion for wildlife. Rather than sticking to a traditional, textbook-based science lesson on ecosystems, the teacher could adapt the lesson to include more hands-on, active learning opportunities. Sam could be tasked with building a model ecosystem, researching animal interactions within that habitat, or even going on a nature walk to observe local wildlife and creating a nature journal. These activities would speak to Sam’s interests and also channel his energy into productive learning, leading to a more engaged and effective understanding of the subject.
Dyslexia
Adapting the curriculum for learners with dyslexia involves a carefully considered approach that addresses the specific challenges these students face in reading and processing written information. Dyslexia affects each individual differently, so it's crucial to implement strategies that cater to these diverse needs. Here are some effective methods:
Multi-sensory Learning: Incorporate visual, auditory, and tactile elements into lessons to reinforce understanding and retention of information. For example, pairing text with images or using audio recordings can help students better grasp the material.
Assistive Technology: Utilize tools such as text-to-speech software, audiobooks, or digital note-taking apps to support reading and writing tasks. These technologies can make reading more accessible and reduce the frustration often associated with dyslexia.
Alternative Assessments: Offer various ways for students to demonstrate their understanding, such as oral presentations, visual projects, or hands-on activities, rather than relying solely on written assignments or tests.
These strategies provide some insight into some of the many ways dyslexia can impact learning. Each learner’s experience with dyslexia is unique, so again it’s important to observe and experiment with different approaches to find what works best. By adapting the curriculum to meet these needs, educators can create a more inclusive learning environment that not only supports academic success but also builds confidence and self-esteem in students with dyslexia.
For example, consider a student named Emma who has dyslexia and a strong interest in history. Instead of assigning a traditional written report on a historical figure, the teacher could adapt the assignment to play to Emma’s strengths. Emma might create a visual timeline of important events, use text-to-speech software to compose a digital presentation, or even collaborate on a project that involves role-playing key moments in history. By allowing Emma to engage with the material in a way that suits her learning style, the teacher can help her develop a deeper understanding of the content and achieve more meaningful learning outcomes.
Redefining Success in Education
Recognizing and addressing the unique needs of learners with disabilities is not about diminishing expectations, but about understanding that everyone has different ways of interacting with the world. These adaptations in the curriculum are not meant to shield students from challenges, but to provide a pathway that allows them to engage with learning in a way that respects their individual capacities. The goal is not to change the learner, but to change the approach, ensuring that each student has the tools they need to succeed. Forcing a one-size-fits-all method onto students with disabilities doesn’t strengthen their resolve; it often limits their potential. True education lies in creating an environment where all students, regardless of their differences, can thrive and develop their own unique strengths.
Medical Model vs. Social Model
In understanding disability, two primary frameworks guide how society perceives and responds to individuals with diverse abilities: the social model and the medical model. The medical model, which has historically shaped discussions on disability, views it as a personal issue arising from physical or mental conditions that need treatment or correction. However, the social model, introduced in the 1970s by disability rights activists like the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation (UPIAS) in the UK, challenges this perspective. It argues that disability is not inherent to the individual but is instead created by societal barriers that restrict access and participation. This perspective is important as it shifts the focus from changing the individual to changing society, advocating for more inclusive environments and equal opportunities for all.
Implementing the social model in curriculum adaptation is essential because it redefines the focus from a learner's limitations to the ways in which the educational environment can be tailored to support their unique needs. Instead of seeing the learner's challenges as inherent, this approach emphasizes removing obstacles—whether they are physical, social, or related to teaching methods—so that all students can fully engage with the curriculum. This not only empowers learners by providing the necessary accommodations but also creates a more inclusive classroom where diversity is embraced. By designing the curriculum with the social model in mind, educators enable every student to succeed, ensuring that educational opportunities are accessible and equitable for everyone.
Conclusion
In conclusion, adaptive pedagogy plays an important role in creating an inclusive and responsive educational environment. By recognizing and addressing the diverse needs of learners, this approach ensures that education is not a one-size-fits-all endeavor but a dynamic process tailored to each student's strengths, challenges, and interests. Whether through differentiated instruction, the application of Universal Design for Learning, or the careful consideration of neurodivergence, adaptive pedagogy empowers educators to create meaningful learning experiences give opportunities of educational success to all learners. Embracing the social model of disability further reinforces the importance of designing curriculum and educational practices that remove barriers, enabling every learner to fully engage and thrive. Ultimately, adaptive pedagogy is not just about accommodating differences; it’s about valuing them and harnessing their potential to create a richer, more inclusive educational experience.
References:
Archer D., (2016) The ADHD Advantage: What You Thought Was a Diagnosis May Be Your Greatest Strength. Avery, Print
Attwood T., (2008) The Complete Guide to Asperger’s Syndrome. Jessica Kingsley Publishers, Print.Gardner H., (2006) Multiple Intelligences: New Horizons in Theory and Practice. Basic Books, Print.
Doubet K., Hockett., (2015) Differentiation in Middle and High School: Strategies to Engage All Learners. ASCD, Print.
Flemming F., (2019) VARK Strategies: The definitive guide to VARK. Amazon, Digital.
Gardner H., (2011) Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences. Basic Books, Print.
Hensley S., (2014) Home Schooling Children with Special Needs. Redemption Press, Print
Inclusion London., The Social Model of Disability. https://www.inclusionlondon.org.uk/about-us/disability-in-london/social-model/the-social-model-of-disability-and-the-cultural-model-of-deafness/
Leicestershire Partnership NHS Trust., Special interests: How to build on these in school. https://www.leicspart.nhs.uk/autism-space/education/special-interests-how-to-build-on-these-in-school/
Mancil G., Pearl C., Restricted Interests as Motivators: Improving Academic Engagement and Outcomes of Children on the Autism Spectrum. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ967728.pdf
Meyer A., et al. (2013) Universal Design for Learning: Theory and Practice. Cast Incorporated, Print.
Steiner R. (1996) The Education of the Child: And Early Lectures on Education. Steiner Books, Print.
Steiner R. (1996) The Foundations of Human Experience. Trans. by Robert F. Lathe and Nancy Parsons Whittaker. Anthroposophic, Print.
Sousa d., Tomlinson C., (2018) Differentiation and the Brain: How Neuroscience Supports the Learner-Friendly Classroom. Solution Tree Press, Print.
Tomlinson C., (2016) Differentiated Classroom, The: Responding to the Needs of All Learners. ASCD, Print.
Wood R., Autism, Intense Interests and Support in School: From Wasted Efforts to Shared Understandings. University of Glasgow, https://eprints.gla.ac.uk/273222/1/273222.pdf